Bruce Pask: Jeremy Renner is the next-gen leading man—interestingly handsome with a great physique. I think he would look great in something a bit sleek, like a thin notch-lapelled tuxedo from Calvin Klein. Worn with a plain white straight collar shirt and a slender black silk satin tie, no pocket square, this would be a clean, sharp look for him. Simple black leather lace-ups please.
Brad Goreski: He could do Prada or Calvin Klein, maybe something with a bit of a shine or even navy. I think he’s really a hidden style gem.
Madeline Weeks: Oh, he’s gorgeous and super sexy. He would look great in Dolce & Gabbana—slimmer lapel, skinny pants. Black tux, single breasted. He would even look great in a shawl collar. On him I’m not opposed to a straight tie.
Ilaria Urbinati: Burberry all the way. They make my favorite tuxes. They’re definitely my Oscar go-to. I would keep him sharp and polished as hell and keep him away from colored tuxes.
Ellen Mirojnick: Tux: Slim lapel shawl collar. Shirt: Black jet spread collar with small black studs, one button French cuff, and matching links. Neck: Perfect bow tie. Shoe: Black evening boot.